Debate grows over preaching on commuter trains

Debate is growing over whether religious preaching should be allowed on commuter trains, following public discussion around Metrorail’s rules on the use of shared transport spaces.

While some argue that preaching is a protected expression of faith, Metrorail maintains that such activity is not permitted on trains as it can disrupt commuters.

Professor Jonathan Jansen, education expert and author, says trains create a captive environment where passengers cannot easily opt out of religious messages.

"I do think it is not fair to those who are not Christians, who don't want to be told, so just like if it were a rabbi or an imam doing the same thing."

Drawing on his own experience as a former train preacher, Jansen said faith should be practised in spaces where people choose to participate, particularly in a diverse, multi-faith society.

"It's a sensitive issue because we are multi-faith; so many people believe different things. To take advantage...I don't know in a democracy."

He warned against resolving the issue through legislation, callinginstead for wisdom and mutual respect.

"When you're sitting in a crammed third-class carriage, you can't go anywhere. It's more a question of wisdom than law. I would hate the legislation saying you can, or you can't do this on the train, but I like the notion of respecting people who believe differently or not at all."

To listen to Jonathan Jansen in conversation with CapeTalk's Lester Kiewit, click the audio below: