Religious freedom has limits, says CRL Rights Commission after KwaSizabantu report withdrawal

The Cultural, Religious and Linguistic (CRL) Rights Commission recently retracted its report on the KwaSizabantu Christian Mission, where it was investigating violations of religious freedoms.

The investigation took place between 2020 and 2022, following allegations of abuse and rape that surfaced during that time.

According to the commission, the move is intended to allow further dialogue, healing and a more survivor-centred process.

The decision follows mediation with complainants who raised concerns about aspects of the original investigation and launched court action.

The commission emphasised that the withdrawal was administrative and does not imply any admission of wrongdoing.

CRL Commissioner Dr Rajendran Govender says religious freedom in South Africa is strongly protected, but not absolute.

"Religious practices would include discipline that must always be exercised within the boundaries of our Constitution. Where practices undermine human dignity, bodily integrity, equality or the rights of children and vulnerable persons, the state has a responsibility to intervene. The role of the CRL is to help society navigate that balance, protecting religious freedom while safeguarding constitutional rights."

Govender adds that further engagements and investigations into the KwaSizabantu matter are expected as the commission works toward a resolution that balances religious freedom with constitutional protections.

To listen to Dr Rajendran Govender in conversation with CapeTalk's Lester Kiewit, click the audio below: