Zoleka Qodashe8 July 2025 | 16:52

Mbenenge only wanted a sexual relationship with Mengo, claims evidence leader

Advocate Salome Scheepers said it was unlikely that Mbenenge pursued Mengo with the interest of developing a romantic relationship as he was already married.

Mbenenge only wanted a sexual relationship with Mengo, claims evidence leader

Eastern Cape Judge President Selby Mbenenge on the witness stand at the Judicial Conduct Tribunal probing allegations of misconduct against him on 8 July 2025. Picture: Sphamandla Dlamini/EWN

JOHANNESBURG - Evidence leader in the Judicial Conduct Tribunal investigating Eastern Cape Judge President Selby Mbenenge claimed that the judge only wanted a sexual relationship with high court secretary, Andiswa Mengo.

Advocate Salome Scheepers said it was unlikely that Mbenenge pursued Mengo with the interest of developing a romantic relationship, as he was already married.

The judge was cross-examined before the tribunal, as it continues investigating sexual harassment allegations levelled against him by his junior staffer.

ALSO READ:

Mbenenge apologises to SA for his 'clandestine chats' with Mengo becoming 'a public spectacle'

Mbenenge rejects assertion that peeled banana emoji he sent to Mengo was meant to be his penis

Mbenenge tells tribunal Mengo used endearing terms towards him

Mbenenge denies sending pornographic material to Mengo

Mbenenge denied the accusations, but was particularly ruffled when Scheepers introduced his marital status in her questioning.

Scheepers: "To have a romantic relationship with someone in the hopes of marrying someone or having a close relationship with that person."

Mbenenge: "Correct."

Scheepers: "In fact, unfortunately, in this instance, you are already a married man."

Mbenenge: "What has that to do with these proceedings, ma’am?"

Scheepers: "Who did not want a serious relationship? Ms mengo? You wanted a sexual relationship with her."

Mbenenge: "Evidence leader, I urge you and I appeal to you that you don’t pose questions to me that are not relevant to the issue at hand."