Mbenenge only wanted a sexual relationship with Mengo, claims evidence leader
Advocate Salome Scheepers said it was unlikely that Mbenenge pursued Mengo with the interest of developing a romantic relationship as he was already married.
Eastern Cape Judge President Selby Mbenenge on the witness stand at the Judicial Conduct Tribunal probing allegations of misconduct against him on 8 July 2025. Picture: Sphamandla Dlamini/EWN
JOHANNESBURG - Evidence leader in the Judicial Conduct Tribunal investigating Eastern Cape Judge President Selby Mbenenge claimed that the judge only wanted a sexual relationship with high court secretary, Andiswa Mengo.
Advocate Salome Scheepers said it was unlikely that Mbenenge pursued Mengo with the interest of developing a romantic relationship, as he was already married.
The judge was cross-examined before the tribunal, as it continues investigating sexual harassment allegations levelled against him by his junior staffer.
ALSO READ:
• Mbenenge apologises to SA for his 'clandestine chats' with Mengo becoming 'a public spectacle'
• Mbenenge rejects assertion that peeled banana emoji he sent to Mengo was meant to be his penis
• Mbenenge tells tribunal Mengo used endearing terms towards him
• Mbenenge denies sending pornographic material to Mengo
Mbenenge denied the accusations, but was particularly ruffled when Scheepers introduced his marital status in her questioning.
Scheepers: "To have a romantic relationship with someone in the hopes of marrying someone or having a close relationship with that person."
Mbenenge: "Correct."
Scheepers: "In fact, unfortunately, in this instance, you are already a married man."
Mbenenge: "What has that to do with these proceedings, ma’am?"
Scheepers: "Who did not want a serious relationship? Ms mengo? You wanted a sexual relationship with her."
Mbenenge: "Evidence leader, I urge you and I appeal to you that you don’t pose questions to me that are not relevant to the issue at hand."