Phala Phala case heads for trial within a trial

Thabiso Goba
3 October 2025 | 13:00The adult male cannot be named due to an order in the case preventing the media from identifying witnesses.
Imanuwela David, along with siblings Floriana and Ndilinasho Joseph, are accused of breaking into President Cyril Ramaphosa’s game farm in February 2020 and stealing $580,000 in cash. Picture: Katlego Jiyane/EWN
The Phala Phala case is heading for a trial within a trial, after a state witness told the court he was illiterate and signed a police statement he didn't understand.
The adult male cannot be named due to an order in the case preventing the media from identifying witnesses.
ALSO READ:
- Phala Phala general manager tells court he called Ramaphosa after break-in, not police
- Phala Phala general manager testifies he was unaware money was hidden in compound
During his brief testimony on Wednesday at the Modimolle Regional Court in Limpopo, the witness said he was an old friend of all three of the accused.
Imanuwela David and siblings, Froliana and Ndilinasho Joseph, are charged with breaking into President Cyril Ramaphosa's farm and stealing $580,000 in cash.
The witness previously told the court he cannot read or write, prompting the state prosecutor to make an application for a trial within a trial to determine whether his signed police statement can be used as evidence in this case.
"Consequently, I grant the request and order that a trial within a trial be held in these proceedings in order to establish if the witness made the statement or the police came with an already written statement for him to sign," said Magistrate Peter Manthata.
Get the whole picture 💡
Take a look at the topic timeline for all related articles.
Trending News
More in Local
3 October 2025 14:30
Team of SA police investigators being sent to France to work with authorities in probing death of Nathi Mthethwa
3 October 2025 14:15
Constitutional Court rules there is no urgency for the Umkhonto Wesizwe party's bid against the presidency
3 October 2025 14:00
Suspected Phala Phala burglary mastermind allegedly bought over R4 million in luxury cars