ISS proposes rules to shield SAPS from political interference

The Institute for Security Studies (ISS) has proposed new rules to protect South Africa’s police service from improper political interference.

In a submission to the Parliamentary Ad Hoc Committee, the ISS has argued that legislation should be passed to reduce the potential for improper interference.

It comes as allegations against suspended police minister Senzo Mchunu are currently being investigated by both the Madlanga Commission and a Parliamentary Ad Hoc Committee.

The ISS is recommending that all ministerial instructions be in writing, discussed with the National Commissioner, and submitted to Parliament for review.

The ISS also suggests defining certain 'off-limits' areas to ministers, such as investigations, public-order operations, and personnel decisions.

Similar rules exist in Kenya, New Zealand, and parts of Australia.

David Bruce, an ISS consultant, says the goal is to ensure police can work independently, while still allowing the government to provide oversight.

Bruce says the issue of political interference has been an ongoing one in South Africa for some time.

"It was also an issue that was highlighted in the report of the Marikana Commission."

Bruce says the first issue in seeking to safeguard against abuses of power is one of transparency.

Written directives help with that, he says.

"One wants any directive to be reduced to writing."

Bruce says protecting police from inappropriate political interference is intended to support them when it comes to applying high standards of judgment based on the law and their expertise.

"At this point, all we know is that the committee has acknowledged receipt of the submission," says Bruce.

To listen to Bruce in conversation with CapeTalk's Clarence Ford, click below: